User Tools

For AI agents: This article is the human-readable version. To check whether an argument commits a fallacy, use the machine-readable Check Fallacies tool — start with the Instructions for AIs.

(Argumentum) ad Virum

Latin: “Argument against the man”: a variant of “(argumentum) ad hominem” in which it is explicitly pointed out that a male person is being targeted, or that a specifically masculine trait is being attacked.

An example that has, unfortunately, been heard all too often lately:

As an old white man, you’d better keep your mouth shut on this topic.

It is hard to imagine a topic in which the speaker's age and/or gender alone would justify excluding them from the discussion.

Note: Although the Latin word „hŏmo“ (whose accusative singular is „hominem“) can also refer to a “male person”, in this context of the phrase „argumentum ad hominem“ it is used to mean “human being” or “person”; that is, it explicitly implies no specific gender here.1)

Using the gender-specific variants “ad virum ” and “ad feminam” are therefore only appropriate when the gender of the person being attacked is relevant to the argument – for example, because a gender-specific characteristic is explicitly being attacked, as in the example above.

See also

1)
Note that the English word “man” also has both meanings Etymological fallacy § Man.

This website uses cookies. By using the website, you agree with storing cookies on your computer. Also, you acknowledge that you have read and understand our Privacy Policy. If you do not agree, please leave the website.

More information